Colorado Rockies: The four most disappointing players of 2019

Daniel Murphy

I’m not sure signing a 34-year-old coming off a -1.0 WAR season counts as a major acquisition, but still, signing Daniel Murphy was the biggest splash that the Rox made this offseason. Sure, no one thought that we were getting prime 2016 Murphy – he of the .347/.390/.595 triple-slash line – but you had to think that the top brass expected more than the barely above replacement level .279/.328/.452 that the Rockies got.

The former second baseman also struggled with his move to first, compiling a -0.5 dWAR with nine errors. Those miscues were tied for sixth-most among all MLB first basemen, despite the fact that Murphy started only 98 games at the position.

Murphy is still signed for one more year (not counting a 2021 mutual option that is almost certainly not going to be exercised), so maybe he can salvage some value in 2020. If he doesn’t rebound though it seems like we’re looking at Ian Desmond 2.0.

Wade Davis

When the 2018 season closed, Wade Davis’ job was as secure as any closer in baseball. He had just finished leading the league in saves (43), setting the Rockies’ team record in the process.

He continued his successful run into the start of 2019, rattling off five straight saves with a microscopic 0.77 ERA. Then things started to get a little rougher. He completed his next save, but gave up two runs in the process. Then allowed a run in his next outing. From June 13-19, he gave up eight runs in four appearances. By the end of June, his ERA was up to 6.00 and many pundits were calling for his job to go to Scott Oberg, who was outpitching Davis by almost every metric.

More from Rox Pile

• A Colorado Rockies Thanksgiving
• Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
• Colorado Rockies: Charlie Blackmon out for the season
• Colorado Rockies: Injuries shift look of roster ahead of Dodgers series
• Colorado Rockies: Has Sean Bouchard earned a second look in 2023?

Oberg was officially given the job at the beginning of August after an ugly loss in which Davis gave up five runs in one-third of an inning. His record officially sat at 1-5 with a 6.82 ERA, and you’d like to think that that’s as bad as it would get … but you’d be wrong.

Davis continued to struggle in low-pressure middle relief outings that only pushed his ERA higher and higher. He finished out the year with two four-run debacles that left his ERA at an eye-poppingly awful 8.65, worth -1.3 WAR overall.

It’s possible that bad luck played at least a partial role in Davis’ collapse, as he had a higher-than-average .349 BABIP and lower-than-average 55.4% strand rate. His FIP and xFIP were 5.56 and 5.80, respectively. Those are not good marks, to be certain, but a far cry from his actual ERA.

The Rockies are on the hook for $17M for Davis’ services next season, which means that he’s almost certain to be on the roster to start the year. This is one of those seasons that went so bad you have to think some correction is in order, though at 34 years old, it seems unlikely that we’ll ever see prime Kansas City Royals-era Wade Davis again.

Brendan Rodgers

This was supposed to be the year that uber-prospect Brendan Rodgers broke through to the majors and staked his claim to a starting job in Denver for years to come. Well, that prediction was half-right, as Rodgers did make his major league debut this season, but let’s just say that he didn’t have the same kind of success at the major league level that he’d had in the minors.

Colorado Rockies

When Rodgers was called up, he had a beautiful .350/.413/.622 slash line at AAA Albuquerque and looked poised to take over the second base job from the struggling Garrett Hampson. Unfortunately, instead of continuing this run of success, Rodgers’ bat went ice cold and he hit only .246/.300/.277 before being sent back to AAA.

That demotion was short-lived, however, and Rodgers was back in the majors less than a week later … where he continued to struggle, then got hurt. Rodgers had season-ending shoulder surgery in July, finishing with just two doubles and zero homers in 81 plate appearances, good for -0.8 WAR.

Lots of prospects struggle in their first taste of MLB action and, of all the players on this list, Rodgers may have the best chance of improving his fortunes in 2020. His shoulder is expected to be 100% by spring training and Rodgers will most likely be given the chance to earn an MLB job in 2020.

Now for the bonus pick who broke a lot of Colorado hearts this year.

DJ LeMahieu

Rockies fans have long known what the rest of the baseball world came to realize this season: DJ LeMahieu is a pretty darn good baseball player. It was both joyful and heartbreaking to watch DJ have so much success with the Yankees this season as the former Rockie set career highs in a bunch of offensive categories including hits, runs, RBI, doubles, homers, slugging, and OPS+.

Some of that may be attributable to the ping pong ball that was used instead of a standard baseball this year, but still a breakout like this can’t be ignored. What makes it sting even more is the fact that the Yanks signed LeMahieu for only $12M a year, which, for those keeping count, is just slightly more than the $10M that the Rox paid the older, less durable Murphy to be a replacement-level first baseman.

Here’s a depressing what if: what if, instead of signing Murphy, the Rockies re-signed DJ and played him at second, with Ryan McMahon handling first for the bulk of the season and Garrett Hampson playing outfield. The Rockies would have been better on both sides of the ball, plus they would’ve scored emotional points for keeping one of their favorite talents in the fold.

Instead, the Rockies faithful will just have to settle for watching DJ fight for a World Series berth with his new team, which, by the way, also features our old friend Adam Ottavino (1.90 ERA, 2.2 WAR) coming out of the bullpen. And to think, if health and fortune had cooperated DJ and Otto could have even been playing beside former franchise cornerstone Troy Tulowitzki as well.

C’est la vie; on to 2020.