Boone Logan: 2014 Colorado Rockies Player Grade

facebooktwitterreddit

Boone Logan signed a three-year, $16.5 million deal with the Colorado Rockies before the 2014 season. To say that his first season did not go well would be a vast understatement. 

Disaster. It seemed that the word ‘disaster’ did not adequately describe Boone Logan’s first season with the Colorado Rockies. So, I did what I am not often inclined to do. I went to Thesaurus.com.

More from Colorado Rockies News

Here are our options: catastrophe, debacle, fiasco, holocaust (yikes), setback, tragedy, defeat, calamity…I’m going with calamity.

Boone Logan’s 2014 season was a calamity.

Health was part of the problem. Logan was limited to only 35 games and 25 innings of work. But bad pitching was a bigger part of the problem.

Logan had a 6.84 ERA, a 63 ERA+, and surrendered six home runs. That’s as many home runs as he surrendered in 55.1 innings in 2012. Whether Logan’s ineffectiveness was caused by the bone chips in his elbow or not, it was altogether discouraging that the Rockies paid the most money to one of their worst relievers.

You know how the Rockies have run poor Matt Belisle into the ground? They overused Belisle over the course of a number of seasons, and now he just isn’t the same. Belisle is a free agent, and the Rockies would be crazy to go down that road again.

Now imagine if the Rockies decided to sign Belisle to a three-year, $16.5 million deal this off-season. Isn’t that kinda what happened with Logan? The Rockies signed him to that deal coming off a stretch of four seasons in which Logan pitched in 51, 64, 80, and 61 games for the New York Yankees. They also signed him knowing about the bone chips in his pitching elbow.

What would have possibly gone wrong?

Needless to say, the Rockies need to temper expectations for Logan in 2015 and possibly beyond. Any usefulness could salvage something out of this contract. More importantly, the Rockies need to learn from this mistake and not overpay in the bullpen. Their margin for error is simply too thin.

Grade for Boone Logan: F.

Grade for the front office for signing Boone Logan: F minus.

More from Rox Pile