Rockies shockingly option potential fifth starter in rotation

Adael Amador and Tanner Gordon were among the Rockies' cuts from Tuesday as the team reduces its roster in preparation for Opening Day next Friday in Miami.

It's important to share that Gordon was on track to complete the Rockies' rotation following a strong spring training, even with the introduction of a new two-seam fastball and adjustments to his changeup grip.

He posted a 1.64 ERA over 11 innings pitched this spring, including a recent four inning performance against the Angels where he allowed one run on four hits, with one walk and four strikeouts.

Gordon competed with Rockies pitchers Ryan Feltner and former top prospect Chase Dollander for the final rotation spot.

Given his improved performance, I expected Colorado, with their new approach, to keep Gordon on the Opening Day roster. That would have surprised many, especially with Dollander on the outside looking in.

Dollander has had an up-and-down spring training, most recently giving up five runs (four earned) on five hits while walking three and striking out four in 3.2 innings on Tuesday.

Dollander possesses the tools of a top-tier starting pitcher, boasting a fastball in the 97-100 mph range and a devastating wipeout slider. However, command issues have surfaced, with seven walks allowed in 14 spring innings.

It's becoming increasingly clear that the Rockies will lean on Dollander as their fifth starter, especially given Ryan Feltner'sstruggles since returning from an injury that sidelined him for most of the 2025 season, as he also competed for the position.

Feltner started Tuesday's exhibition game against the Mariners, giving up three runs on three hits with four walks and two strikeouts. Similar to Dollander, Feltner possesses good swing-and-miss potential, but his command has been inconsistent.

Feltner has allowed ten free passes this spring in 11.2 innings pitched, but he's demonstrated the ability to strike out batters with 14 strikeouts. I've always seen Feltner as a potential bullpen arm with high upside, especially with his wipeout stuff, but the walks have been a concern.

While Gordon performed well in spring training, Colorado is likely prioritizing Dollander's development and avoiding a demotion that could damage his confidence. It's important to remember that during spring training, players are often experimenting with new pitches and grips, rather than focusing solely on the numbers.