Top 5 players to play for the Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers

2 of 3

OAKLAND, CA – JULY 29: David Dahl #26 of the Colorado Rockies bats during the game against the Oakland Athletics at RingCentral Coliseum on July 29, 2020 in Oakland, California. The Rockies defeated the Athletics 5-1. (Photo by Michael Zagaris/Oakland Athletics/Getty Images) /

This list was admittedly a little hard to make. The Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers do not share as many players as some of the other teams we have looked at, so sadly we don’t see anyone like Nolan Ryan on this list (though eventually Trevor Story may make his way onto this list), but it is always fun to look into the histories of these teams.

Here are the Top 5 players to play for the Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers.

Total Number of Shared Players: 61

Players to play exclusively for the Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers:

Cliff Brumbaugh

David Dahl

Chi Chi Gonzalez

Honorable Mentions:

Chi Chi Gonzalez

Todd Hollandsworth

Jonathan Lucroy

Jordan Lyles

Kevin Millwood

5. David Dahl

More from Colorado Rockies All-Time Lists

David Dahl probably should not be on this list because of his limited time with the Texas Rangers. After all, he only just signed with the team this offseason, but his current contract has him under control through 2024. Unless traded, David Dahl will be on the Texas Rangers for a good chunk of time.

While early on has been a little rough for Dahl in Texas, I believe he has the potential to top this list in a future iteration. Just like his time with the Colorado Rockies, injuries will dictate his legacy. Currently, David Dahl is yet again on the injured list, but he is only 27 years old and already has an All-Star appearance under his belt. We will watch his Rangers career with great interest.

Colorado Rockies’ pitcher Jason Jennings delivers a pitch to Florida Marlins’ outfielder Preston Wilson During sixth inning action 12 August, 2002, at Pro Player Stadium in Miami Florida. AFP PHOTO/RHONA WISE (Photo by RHONA WISE / AFP) (Photo credit should read RHONA WISE/AFP via Getty Images) /

4. Jason Jennings

Drafted in the first round of the 1999 draft, Jason Jennings made his debut in 2001 with only seven starts. Jennings’ true rookie year was in 2002, when he started 32 games and posted exceptionally high stats for a Colorado Rockies pitcher. While he didn’t lead the league in any factors, he had a great 16-8 record, an above-average 106 ERA+, and struck out 6.2 batters per nine innings pitched. Seeing a pitcher who could pitch at the dreaded Coors Field left the league stunned enough to grant Jennings the only Rookie of the Year award in Rockies history.

Jason Jennings’ career seemed to peak with the accolades of his rookie season though. He was a part of some terrible Rockies rotations and was let go after the 2006 season, which was the best season of his career. Jennings would only be in the Majors for three more seasons after leaving the Rockies, his last two being with the Texas Rangers.

Jason Jennings was a terrible starter for the Rangers in 2008 and in 2009 they moved him to the bullpen. While still posting a losing record, he was significantly better pitching out of the bullpen, posting a 113 ERA+ with 6.5 strikeouts per nine innings pitched, tied for the highest rate of his career. Jason Jennings is a case of a player who seemed worse than he was because of the high expectations his early career set upon him.

3. Eric Young Sr.

More from Colorado Rockies All-Time Lists

Eric Young Sr. is one of the less talked about members of the Blake Street Bombers back in 1995. While he didn’t hit home runs, Young Sr. was fast, he was able to take bases that just simply weren’t there for other players. This resulted in a .317 batting average and an .404 on-base percentage in 1995. During the Rockies’ first-ever postseason run against the Braves, Young Sr. was fantastic throughout the series, but was critical during the Rockies’ solitary win, hitting a two-run home run in a game that the Rockies would win in extra innings.

This hot streak kept going into 1996 when Young Sr. earned himself an All-Star appearance along with a Silver Slugger. That year, he led the league in Steals and batted .324, the highest batting average of his career.

Eric Young Sr. saw the best of his last five seasons in Texas, batting .288 with a .377 OBP. Throughout his career, Young Sr. was good at compiling walks right along with hits. It also helped that he was speedy, a trait his son would inherit from him, who would lead the league in steals in 2013.

Sep 18, 2019; Denver, CO, USA; Colorado Rockies left fielder Ian Desmond (20) accepts the Roberto Clemente Award before a game against the New York Mets at Coors Field. Mandatory Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports /

2. Ian Desmond

While I am not positive he will make the list when it comes time to talk about the Washington Nationals in September (seriously I may have to make a separate list just for former Expos players and Nationals players separately because that list is stacked), I will plan on talking more about the exploits of Ian Desmond in that article.

In short, he was an All-Star during his one season with the Texas Rangers in 2016. The Rockies signed him in 2017 and moved to first base as the team was overstocked with outfielders at the time. During the three seasons he has played for Colorado, Desmond had never produced a positive WAR for the team, but that does not mean it was all terrible. He was a part of both of the Rockies’ postseason runs in 2017 and 2018 and hit more than 20 home runs for both the Rangers in 2017 and the Rockies in 2018 and 2019. While not consistent, Ian Desmond showed power with both teams.

1. Yorvit Torrealba

Colorado Rockies

I have covered Yorvit Torrealba on another list already, so I will cover the broad strokes here. He was the primary catcher for the Rockies during the 2007 World Series run whose bat was clutch for the team’s playoff hopes in both 2007 and 2009.

On the Giants list, Torrealba was only number 5, he played more for the Giants (five seasons) than the Rangers (two seasons), so why put him so high here and not there? First, go back and look, that Top 5 Rockies/Giants list was absolutely loaded with Rockies greats. Second, Torrealba was the primary catcher for the Texas Rangers in 2011 for their second failed World Series run.

While not fantastic for the Rangers behind the plate, Torrealba was very good in front of it, producing the second-highest oWAR of his career during that season, even better than was when he was with the Rockies. While there are players who arguably should be in front of Torrealba on this list in terms of overall talent, he is easily the player on this list to contribute the most to both the Rockies and Rangers, specifically, making him the easy choice for number one on the list.

dark. Next. Top 5 players to play for the Colorado Rockies and Pittsburgh Pirates

Note: Data for this article was found using Baseball Reference

Home / Colorado Rockies All-Time Lists

Here are the Top 5 players to play for the Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers.

Total Number of Shared Players: 61

Players to play exclusively for the Colorado Rockies and Texas Rangers:

Honorable Mentions:

5. David Dahl

4. Jason Jennings

3. Eric Young Sr.

More from Colorado Rockies All-Time Lists

2. Ian Desmond

1. Yorvit Torrealba

Colorado Rockies

Schedule