Colorado Rockies: Top Five Third Basemen in Franchise History

Number 4: Garrett Atkins (5.3 bWAR, 7.6 fWAR, parts of 7 years as a Rockie)

Garrett Atkins is a bit hard to rank considering that his best seasons were really great but he dropped like a lead balloon. He also only spent four of the seven seasons as primary third baseman. In the other three seasons, Atkins accumulated -2.3 bWAR/-1.8 fWAR so that’s obviously not what got him on this list. But in the other four seasons (the four main seasons that he was the primary third baseman), he had 7.3 bWAR/9.5 fWAR.

Here’s look at his overall stats from his Rockies tenure.

Of the four primary seasons, two stand out offensively: 2006 and 2007. However, his fielding is what has the big differentiation in WAR between FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference.

By WAR, his best two seasons were 2005 and 2006 per Baseball-Reference but FanGraphs says that his best two seasons were 2006 and 2007.

Both sites are in agreement, though, that he was awful defensively in 2007 as he has -26 DRS from both sites.

His peak would have him at number three but considering his rise and fall was so quick and dramatic, he is at number four.

Number 3: Jeff Cirillo (7.9 bWAR, 6.9 fWAR, 2 seasons as Rockie)

Like Charlie Hayes, Jeff Cirillo spent only two of his 14 year MLB career with the Rockies and he bounced around to a few different teams, particularly after he left the Rockies.

The Rockies acquired Cirillo in Dealin’ Dan O’Dowd’s first offseason as Rockies GM as he was hired in September of ’99 and Cirillo was acquired in December of ’99.

It was a three-team trade that looked like this:

It was O’Dowd’s second trade of the day involving third basemen on our list as someone coming up on our list was traded away on the same day. These would be the Rockies’ last two trades of the 20th century and the Millenium. They were also O’Dowd’s 5th and 6th trades of the offseason (that’s why he was nicknamed Dealin’ Dan).

Cirillo was an All-Star in his first season as Rockie as he also had a great bat for contact and driving in runs. However, he hit for little power.

In 2000, he had 195 hits, 111 runs, 115 RBI, 53 doubles, and a batting average and on-base percentage of .326 and .392. He also walked nearly as often as he struck out (67 walks and only 72 strikeouts). However, with those 115 RBI, he had an astonishingly low 11 home runs and, therefore, a .477 slugging percentage and an OPS+ below league average (99).

In 2001, he hit .313/.364/.473 with 17 home runs, 83 RBI, 26 doubles, and an OPS+ of 98. His WAR in the two seasons is pretty good because defensively, he was very good. Per FanGraphs, he had 29 TZ (Total Zone rating, which is the predecessor to Defensive Runs Saved, which started to be calculated in 2003) in his two seasons as a Rockie.

Dealin’ Dan dealt Cirillo to the Mariners after the 2001 season for Jose Paniagua, Denny Stark, and a guy by the name of Brian Fuentes so it ended up being a pretty good deal for the Rockies.

That trade and the trade that brought Cirillo to the Rockies will be part of an investigation that we will have here at Rox Pile in the next few days so stay tuned for that soon.

Number 2: Vinny Castilla (17.5 bWAR, 15.7 fWAR, parts of 9 seasons as a Rockie)

Vinny Castilla was an original Colorado Rockie, like Charlie Hayes, but at first, he played shortstop for the Rockies in 1993. He was mainly relegated to the bench in 1994 due to the acquisition of Walt Weiss to play shortstop.

When Hayes left after 1994, though, the Rockies turned to Castilla to replace him. Obviously, that ended up being an excellent decision for the Rockies and great for Castilla. The Rockies moved to Coors Field that season and along with Larry Walker, Dante Bichette, Andres Galarraga, and Ellis Burks, Castilla became a part of the Blake Street Bombers.

In 1995, he hit 32 home runs and 90 RBI with an OPS+ of 113. He also became an All-Star for the first time, came in 18th in NL MVP voting, and won an NL Silver Slugger Award.

In the next four seasons, Castilla averaged 40 home runs, 118 RBI, and a slash line of .301/.348/.541. In those four seasons, he was an All-Star once more, won two Silver Slugger Awards, and ranked twice in NL MVP voting.

More from Rox Pile

• A Colorado Rockies Thanksgiving
• Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
• Colorado Rockies: Charlie Blackmon out for the season
• Colorado Rockies: Injuries shift look of roster ahead of Dodgers series
• Colorado Rockies: Has Sean Bouchard earned a second look in 2023?

Dealin’ Dan O’Dowd traded Castilla to the Tampa Bay Devil Rays for Rolando Arrojo and Aaron Ledesma on the same day he acquired Jeff Cirillo from Milwaukee to replace him.

Castilla suffered knee injuries in Tampa due to the turf playing surface so they traded him to Houston and later, Castilla played for the Braves but he hadn’t returned to his former ways.

He returned to the Rockies in 2004 where he returned to his former glory as he hit 35 home runs and had a league-leading 131 RBI along with a slash line of .271/.332/.535 and an OPS+ of 109. He came in 22nd in NL MVP voting. It was the first time he had an OPS+ above 100 for a full season or 100+ RBI in a season since he had left the Rockies.

He left the Rockies again but this time, via free agency. He went to the Nationals (for their first season in Washington, D.C.) and the Padres before returning to the Rockies for a third time in late 2006, where he finished out his career.

Now, he is a special assistant with the Rockies front office and also helps with occasional coaching. He also was part of Kingsford’s Taste of the Game cookbook with recipes from players of each of the 30 teams. We talked to him exclusively in a conversation about that, his baseball career, what he’s doing now, and what may be in store for him in the future. You can read here.

Number 1: Nolan Arenado (37.5 bWAR, 31.3 fWAR, 7 seasons as a Rockie)

Was there any doubt? If you did have any, you shouldn’t have because chances are, if you are reading this, you know that Nolan Arenado is one of the best Rockies to ever play.

Arenado is one of, if not, the best third basemen in baseball right now and at his current pace, he could very well go down as the best third basemen in baseball history.

In seven seasons, he has seven Gold Glove Awards, five All-Star appearances, five top ten NL MVP votes, four Silver Slugger Awards, three Platinum Gloves, lead the NL in home runs three times, RBI twice, and doubles and games played in a season once. Now, all he needs is a partridge in a pear tree and he’d be pretty close to the 12 Days of Christmas (or 12 signs of a future Hall of Famer).

There’s a reason why he is the highest-paid player in Rockies history. He isn’t just the best third baseman in franchise history but if he stays with the Rockies for the full length of his contract, he will likely be the best player to ever put on the purple pinstripes.

Only Arenado himself is in control of whether or not he will be a lifelong Rockie.