Colorado Rockies: The 3 emotions around Nolan Arenado’s tough words

Nolan Arenado, the All-Star do-everything third baseman for the Colorado Rockies, raised some eyebrows with some of the comments he made to Nick Groke of The Athletic in this article. For many Rockies fans, Arenado potentially leaving the Rockies when his contract expires at the end of the 2019 season is a numbing thought.

Considered the best in the game today at third base by many, there is no guarantee that Arenado will spend his entire career in a Rockies uniform. Knowing that teams with deep pockets such as the Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees and (yes) even the Los Angeles Dodgers or San Francisco Giants could make a run at Arenado, keeping the 27-year-old Silver Slugger and Platinum Glove winner happy is important for the Rockies if they want to keep him around.

However, it’s apparent in some of Arenado’s quotes, that his level of happiness could boil down to playing for a winning team. That has not been the Rockies in Arenado’s years, save for a way-too-brief postseason appearance in last year’s Wild Card loss in Arizona.

More from Colorado Rockies News

• A Colorado Rockies Thanksgiving
• Colorado Rockies: Charlie Blackmon out for the season
• Colorado Rockies: Injuries shift look of roster ahead of Dodgers series
• Colorado Rockies: 3 things we appreciated from Tuesday in San Francisco
• What Bill Schmidt’s comments mean for the Colorado Rockies in 2023

With the 2018 team fighting to get back to .500, let alone compete for a division crown and postseason berth, Arenado’s quotes come at a difficult time for the Rockies. A gamble on an expensive bullpen seems to have backfired through the first half of the season and those late-game losses could come back to haunt the Rockies when the postseason picture is finalized.

I talked to several friends who read Arenado’s quotes and asked them for their opinions. There were plenty to go around, trust me. However, I think some of their thoughts encapsulate what many Rockies fans are feeling right now.

Using their comments, I broke down the emotional response of the Colorado fan base to Arenado’s quotes into three categories. Let’s take a look at each and what might happen if those emotions play out with Arenado leaving or staying.

The most common theme I heard from friends and colleagues was despair. That Arenado was leaving the franchise and there was nothing that the Rockies could do about it. That this season of struggles had cemented Arenado’s mind on his future … and it wasn’t in Colorado.

Let’s start by saying that there is no guarantee that this will happen. There is no guarantee that Arenado is so beyond frustrated that he is ready to give up. On the contrary, Colorado coaches and players will tell you there is no one who works harder on his craft than Arenado. If something isn’t going right for the Rockies and he can control it, he will work in the cage or on the field to correct the action.

More from Rox Pile

• A Colorado Rockies Thanksgiving
• Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
• Colorado Rockies: Charlie Blackmon out for the season
• Colorado Rockies: Injuries shift look of roster ahead of Dodgers series
• Colorado Rockies: Has Sean Bouchard earned a second look in 2023?

But what if he can’t correct it because he can’t control it? Arenado can’t control where Bryan Shaw throws his cutter or Jon Gray’s inability to stop a potentially big inning from becoming, in reality, a big inning. That is where Arenado’s frustration lies. He can work as hard as he can to be as good as he can, but when others can’t do their jobs, it sometimes negates what even Arenado can do.

Does this mean Arenado is leaving? No, but a level of frustration has clearly built up. Is this new? Hardly. Think back to Arenado exploding on Nick Hundley in the dugout a couple of years ago. You remember that, right?

Colorado general manager Jeff Bridich still has time to pull some strings and do everything he can to show Arenado he’s committed to winning with his All-Star third baseman manning the hot corner. That needs to start now as the trade deadline draws near.

Surprisingly, I heard a lot about anger toward Arenado as well when talking to friends. Comments such as, “He can leave if he doesn’t want to play for Colorado” or “We don’t want someone on the team who is only looking ahead to when he can leave” were said. Of course, I vehemently disagree with this.

I liken it to when Kevin Durant left the Oklahoma City Thunder to chase an NBA championship with the Golden State Warriors. Durant was criticized (and still is) for joining a super team to get a ring. However, Durant’s goal was winning an NBA title and he has succeeded in that while raising his own stature when the conversations of NBA greats is brought up.

Arenado’s goal is winning and playing in the postseason. It’s not selfish or crazy to consider, and I would venture to say that every player in that clubhouse wants the same thing. All of us want to put ourselves in the best possible position in our careers and Arenado may decide to do just that by going to a team in a major market. If it happens, he may well not only increase his chances of winning a World Series, but also scoring a major money deal while playing on national television much more than he currently is.

So if you had the chance to make an unbelievable amount of money and be at the top of your profession, would you? I don’t know of too many friends who have stayed at the same job for their entire career.

Again, let me state, there is no inkling that Arenado is leaving after next season. Yet I am finding a lot of people very upset with his comments already. My advice is simple: Don’t get mad about something that there’s nothing to get mad about. Save the hot takes for the end of the 2019 season … and see if they’re even still applicable then.