Offensively, the two are very similar.
Batting average: Walker .313 and Helton .316
On-base percentage: Walker .400 and Helton .414
Slugging percentage: Walker .565 and Helton .539
Runs: Walker 1355 and Helton 1401
However, the main kicker here is OPS+, which adjusts to parks played in and the era that player played in. With this, it’s still close, but a winner is clear.
OPS+: Walker 141 and Helton 133.
More from Colorado Rockies History
- Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
- The plane crash that changed this Colorado Rockies broadcaster’s life
- The Colorado Rockies have their own “Bobby Bonilla Day” deferred salaries
- Colorado Rockies: Is Ezequiel Tovar on a Troy Tulowitzki-like path to the majors?
- Colorado Rockies: Is the 2022 NL West the best division ever?
Career peaks of Walker and Helton
For Walker, it is fair to say that Walker’s peak was from 1992 through 2002. Outside of these seasons, the only awards that he came close to getting was in 1990, when he was came in seventh in NL Rookie of the Year voting. He also never had more than 19 home runs and 79 RBI outside of these seasons. Between 1992 and 2002, Walker averaged 125 games played per season with 94 runs, 147 hits, 33 doubles, 27 home runs, 92 RBI, 16 stolen bases, a .327/.410/.602 slash line (compared to his .313/.400/.602 career slash line), and an OPS+ of 147 (compared to his career OPS+ of 141).
In comparison, Helton’s peak was from 1998 through 2009 so his peak is one year longer than Walker’s. Helton did not rank in anything outside of these seasons. His average season in this period of time looked like this: 148 games, 101 runs, 176 hits, 42 doubles, 27 home runs, 99 RBI, a .329/.428/.568 slash line (compared to a .316/.414/.539 slash line in his career) and an OPS+ of 141 (compared to 133 in his career).