Colorado Rockies: The 5 most disappointing players in 2017

DENVER, CO - AUGUST 20: Relief pitcher Tyler Chatwood #32 of the Colorado Rockies walks back to the mound after giving up a home run to Jesus Aguilar of the Milwaukee Brewers during the seventh inning at Coors Field on August 20, 2017 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by Justin Edmonds/Getty Images)
DENVER, CO - AUGUST 20: Relief pitcher Tyler Chatwood #32 of the Colorado Rockies walks back to the mound after giving up a home run to Jesus Aguilar of the Milwaukee Brewers during the seventh inning at Coors Field on August 20, 2017 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by Justin Edmonds/Getty Images)
2 of 3
Next

The Colorado Rockies had one of the best seasons in franchise history this year. They nearly won 90 games, and made it clear to all MLB fans they are on the rise. Still, there was room for improvement. In fact, there was five players in particular who disappointed in 2017, and here they are.

Carlos Gonzalez

Why not start off with the obvious decision? Carlos Gonzalez is far and wide the most disappointing player on the Rockies, and one of the most disappointing players in all of baseball. His batting average dropped from .298 all the way down to .262, nearly a 30 point drop. in 2015, CarGo belted 40 home runs. This past year, he only got 14. Gonzalez was once one of the key players for the Rockies, finishing 3rd in the MVP race in 2010. Now, he was lucky to see a spot late in the year, especially with players like Raimel Tapia, who are on the come up.

Just imagine how elite the Rockies offense could have been if CarGo would have played as good as we are used to. If Gonzalez would have been anywhere near as good as he was last year or the year before that, the Rockies would have been good enough to maybe be seen as a legit contender for the World Series.

Trevor Story

It’s unfortunate Story couldn’t really piece together a very good season this year, because everyone was rooting for him. I mean, no pun intended, but he had such a story line coming into this year. Troy Tulowitzki was dealt to Toronto, and Jose Reyes was an astronomical disappointment. Rockies fans’ dreams of seeing an elite shortstop playing in the purple pin stripes was dead. Until the beginning of 2016.

Colorado Rockies
Colorado Rockies /

Colorado Rockies

Trevor Story hit 27 home runs in just 97 games, and would have won Rookie of the Year in a landslide had he not come down with an injury in his thumb. Still, Story was hope the Rockies had a lot to be excited about.

It’s not like Story was awful, but there was definitely disappointment when watching him on the field. Story played 48 more games than the year before, but hit 3 less home runs, with only a .239 batting average and a whopping 191 strikeouts to only 49 walks.

David Dahl

It’s hard for most fans to see the problem with David Dahl. The man was injured for most of the year, and never saw the majors. He has a really good swing, and is a very young player. Dahl played well in major league baseball last year. What’s to be disappointed about?

Sure, he hit .315 last year with 7 home runs in just over 60 games. It’s not like you can blame him for this, but you can certainly be disappointed it happened. During spring training, David Dahl was expected to be playing in the majors as a backup while only missing the first week or so. And, to sum it up, he ended up being injured for months longer than expected, didn’t play at all at the major league level, and his Triple-A stats were awful.

Tyler Chatwood

Luckily for Rockies fans, it doesn’t mean too much that Chatwood was a disappointment, because he won’t be a Rockie for long. Chatwood may have looked alright from a statistical perspective, but he failed the eye test over and over again, walking players and tending to leave the ball in the meat of the strike zone. Bud Black ultimately could no longer take it, and moved him to the bullpen.

Now Chatwood has the option to leave Colorado, and likely will. There is absolutely no reason to panic, though. The Rockies should have plans to completely restart and find a brand new bullpen this off season. Hopefully, we can look back in 2018 and say we do not need Chatwood anymore.

Adam Ottavino

Ottavino is so hard not to have in your bullpen somewhere. He just seems to have that scary word on his name: potential. His off-speed is unmatched, and he can throw the ball pretty hard too. He has shown flashes of greatness and looks to one day be a key contributor in an effective or at least serviceable bullpen.

Next: The flip side: The 5 most successful Rockies of 2017

Or at least that is the hope, but suddenly it is looking somewhat illogical to consider. At age 31, Ottavino had an ERA over 5 and almost gave up a hit every inning he pitched. He struck out a whopping 63 guys in only 53 1/3 innings pitched, but let’s remember the relievers have a much easier time striking out batters than starters do. Ottavino certainly has potential to be a good player, but he was disappointing to watch this season because his walk rate. He averaged 6.6 walks per nine innings. Obviously, that is something that he must reduce in 2018.

Next