Colorado Rockies trade rumors: The shortstop edition

Trevor Story has struggled since his return from thumb surgery that ended his 2016 campaign prematurely.

It’s no secret that Trevor Story has had a poor 2017 performance. His struggles are shown in his stats. In 72 games played, he’s only had 53 hits, 10 doubles, 11 HRs, 32 RBIs, 94 strikeouts, a .218/.301/.395 slash line, an OPS+ of 70, and, according to Fangraphs.com, his wRC+ (weighted Runs Created Plus) is 66. However, his BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) is slightly above average as it’s .304 (.300 is considered above average).

Defensively, also according to Fangraphs, his DRS (Defensive Runs Saved) is only 1 (zero is league average). However, his UZR (Ultimate Zone Rating, which measures his range when fielding) is below average as it is -2.9.

For the Rockies shortstops in general, for all of baseball, they are 23rd in baseball in average (.233), 20th in on-base percentage (.296), 14th in slugging percentage (.417), 21st in hits (77), 19th in doubles (14), tied for 2nd in home runs (15), tied for 3rd in RBIs (50), 11th in runs (45), and last (meaning the most amount) of strikeouts (100), and 8th best in walks (29).

On Wednesday, manager Bud Black benched Story. If Story remains on the bench or even optioned to Triple-A Albuquerque, who are some of the internal and external options for the shortstop positions?

Pat Valaika

Pat Valaika has been on the bench for most of the year for the Rockies and as a whole, in 2017, he hasn’t played extraordinarily as he has a .245/.272/.510 slash line with six homers, 17 RBIs, and an OPS+ of 87. He did have a tremendous game yesterday, though, as he started as shortstop for the Rockies’ last night. He had three hits, a homer, and three RBIs in the Rockies’ 5-3 win against the Reds (the game recap from the game is right here).

Alexi Amarista

Amarista, like Valaika, has spent most of the year on the bench for the Rockies but in 49 games, he has two homers, 16 RBIs, a slash line of .257/.278/.381, and an OPS+ of 61. Given that OPS+ number, he will stay on the bench

Tony Wolters

The only way Tony Wolters would be playing shortstop regularly is if the Rockies’ acquire a catcher at the trade deadline. Wolters has played shortstop on a regular basis in the past, particularly, in the minor leagues when he was with the Cleveland Indians. In 443 career, minor league games, roughly 32.5% of those games were played at shortstop (144 games) compared to 41.5% catching (184 games). He has played shortstop in the Major Leagues, albeit in limited action. In the 126 games he’s played in the majors, he has spent a total of six innings at shortstop (all were in 2016). However, even if the Rockies’ do acquire a catcher at the trade deadline, Wolters would probably be on the bench, not playing shortstop everyday.

Given that this is the time of the year for trades to happen, it wouldn’t be surprising if the Rockies were to look for a shortstop at the trade deadline. Here are some of the options.

Zack Cozart, Cincinnati Reds

The Reds are in last place in the National League Central and the Rockies have seen Zack Cozart the past few days since they have been facing them at Coors Field. On Tuesday, he will be starting for the National League in Miami as starting shortstop and he has played well enough to earn the honor. He, in 63 games, has 75 hits, nine homers, 33 RBIs, a .315/.394/.542, and an OPS+ of 142. He also has performed well defensively as, according to Fangraphs, his UZR is 4.0 and a DRS of 5 (his career high was 19 in 2014). In comparison, Nolan Arenado‘s career high is 30 but he hasn’t been above 18 in the past four years (but he will pass that this year as he’s already at 16). He also is only under control through the end of this season which is a good thing considering that top prospect Brendan Rodgers, who’s currently playing at Advanced-A ball Lancaster, will probably be in the Major Leagues sometime next season. If he’s not, Trevor Story could then return to a starting role.

Asdrubal Cabrera, New York Mets

The Mets are 7.5 under .500 and one of the players that will be traded is Asdrubal Cabrera. He has played in 60 games in 2017 and has 57 hits, eight homers, 24 RBIs, a .260/.341/.420 slash line, and a 101 OPS+. However, defensively, Cabrera has really struggled, according to Fangraphs as his DRS is already -10 and his UZR is -5.6. However, if he were to play next to Nolan Arenado, he would probably benefit from it. He is, like Cozart, only under team control through the end of the season.

Other Options

Some other options include Freddy Galvis of the Philadelphia Phillies, Yunel Escobar of the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, Jose Iglesias of the Detroit Tigers, and Jordy Mercer of the Pittsburgh Pirates. However, none of them have performed particularly well offensively. Escobar is the only player of the other options that have an OPS+ above league average at 109. However, he hasn’t played shortstop since 2014.