Colorado Rockies: Memories of Key Players at Double-A Tulsa

Nolan Arenado

2012 for Tulsa: .285 average, 12 HR, 56 RBI in 134 games

Best game: April 5 at San Antonio: 4-for-5, 3 RBI

“Nolan’s season in Tulsa reminded me a lot of the one Matt Holliday had in Tulsa. Going into the 2012 season, everyone thought Nolan was going to tear up Texas League pitching and be gone in a month. The bar was set high, really as high as it ever was for anyone during the Colorado Rockies days with the Drillers.

“In the field, he was good but not great. You could see the Gold Glove potential on some plays but the consistency just wasn’t there. It was a mixed bag, but he was also very young when he came to Tulsa. He was just about to turn 21 when he got here.

More from Rox Pile

• A Colorado Rockies Thanksgiving
• Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
• Colorado Rockies: Charlie Blackmon out for the season
• Colorado Rockies: Injuries shift look of roster ahead of Dodgers series
• Colorado Rockies: Has Sean Bouchard earned a second look in 2023?

“Hitting-wise, you’d see flashes but he didn’t really tear it up at the plate. His numbers were OK but, when you look back now, you wonder how Nolan Arenado could only have 56 RBI in a full season at Double-A? And just 12 homers? The RBI count is still mysterious to me.

“He seemed to be really pushing but had a talk with (former Colorado general manager) Dan O’Dowd later in the season and that seemed to help him.”

Next: Trevor Story Hits Rockets, Yet Struggles

Trevor Story

2014 for Tulsa: .200 average, 9 HR, 20 RBI in 56 games

Best game: August 23 at Springfield, 3-for-5, 1 RBI

More from Colorado Rockies History

• Colorado Rockies: What if Todd Helton had played football instead?
• The plane crash that changed this Colorado Rockies broadcaster’s life
• The Colorado Rockies have their own “Bobby Bonilla Day” deferred salaries
• Colorado Rockies: Is Ezequiel Tovar on a Troy Tulowitzki-like path to the majors?
• Colorado Rockies: Is the 2022 NL West the best division ever?

“The bar was set high for him as well, especially being a compensation first-round draft pick in 2011. Everyone knew he was coming to Tulsa and he finally got here in 2014 after tearing it up at (Class A) Modesto. Everyone expected him to do the same in Tulsa but he struggled. He hit for more power in Tulsa and I remember the ball just jumped off the bat at times when he hit it. He hit some real rockets and didn’t have any cheap homers. But he also struck out about every one out of 2.5 times at the plate. He also struggled in the playoffs (going 4-for-32 in nine games).

“After Tulsa though, he was a model of consistency in the minors. I think everyone expected him to be fairly successful once he finally reached the Rockies, but never to have the start that he had to his career.”

Next: Jon Gray: A Young, Pure Power Pitcher

Jon Gray

2014 for Tulsa: 10-5, 3.91 ERA, 24 games (all starts)

Best game: August 2 vs. Northwest Arkansas, 7.0 IP, 2 H, 1 ER

“He showed flashes on the mound and had a solid year. I was really surprised when he was with Tulsa during the entire 2014 season. He had only had nine professional outings before coming to Tulsa so I think it was good for him to be here for the entire season. When you’re the third overall selection, that sets the bar pretty high.

“I remember him being on the mound and expecting him to be more dominant. He had good stats but he also got hit around hard at times. In Tulsa, it didn’t look like his fastball had that much movement. It was a straight fastball that had power but not much movement.

Next: Two Prospects Who Should've Made a Bigger Impact

Tim Wheeler

2011 for Tulsa: .287 average, 33 HR, 86 RBI in 138 games

Best game: May 26 at Midland, 3-for-4, 2 HR, 4 RBI

“I thought he would’ve gotten to the Majors. I thought he would’ve found similar success or even be a fourth outfielder for the Colorado Rockies but he just never got there. When he suffered that broken hamate bone, he never regained the power. He wasn’t a player who hit for high enough average so when the power was gone, that was tough. It really was a case of ‘what might have been.’

Chin-hui Tsao

2003 for Tulsa: 11-4, 2.46 ERA, 18 games (all starts)

2004 for Tulsa: 1-1, 2.77 ERA, 2 games (all starts)

Best game: April 3, 2003, vs. Frisco, 6.0 IP, 5 H, 1 ER

“He came into the 2003 season hyped so much. He had a great season for the Drillers and then had a great debut for the Rockies. The sky seemed to be the limit for him. It’s amazing to think that today he has just five big league wins. It’s also amazing to think he’s still plugging away in Triple-A (with the Los Angeles Dodgers organization in Oklahoma City) and that he’s still potentially an option for the Dodgers to call up.

“There are two things that really stand out to me about him. First, in Tulsa, he was a really good athlete who could also handle the bat pretty well. Second, he not only pitched in the very first game for the Rockies organization in Tulsa but also for the Dodgers organization when they debuted in Tulsa 12 years later. What are the odds of that?”

Next: The Top 5 Catchers in Colorado History

Note: Chin-hui Tsao went 0-1 for Tulsa with a 7.20 ERA in four games in 2015. He was also a more highly regarded prospect than Matt Holliday in 2003 and made history by being the first Driller to be called up by Colorado. He also became the first Taiwanese pitcher in MLB, going 3-3 for the Rockies in nine games in 2003.